Discover Heartlake Lodge, a beloved 4.4-star retreat on Heart Lake Rd, Mayfield. Enjoy delicious wings, fresh pizza, local brews, live Friday music, and friendly, prompt service in a scenic lakeside setting perfect for dining, events, and relaxation.
Guests highlight the lodge’s convenient lakeside location, quality food and drink offerings, and attentive service. This welcoming spot suits both casual dining and special occasions, with a lively atmosphere especially on weekends.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Heartlake Lodge, nestled peacefully by the serene waters of Heart Lake in Mayfield, PA, stands out as a charming retreat that blends natural beauty with warm hospitality. With a solid 4.4-star rating, it offers visitors not only a scenic escape but also an inviting atmosphere that makes every stay memorable.
Visitors often praise the Lodge for its vibrant bar and restaurant scene. As George Palickar observed, the lively crowd and the inviting aroma of their famous wings hint at the quality guests can expect. The variety of five beers on tap, including unique heartier brews, complements the well-crafted menu and adds to the convivial ambiance. The promise of live music on Fridays creates an engaging social setting that draws both locals and travelers alike.
Donald Sparacino’s words capture the essence of Heartlake Lodge perfectly—“a beautiful place right by the lake” with excellent food and attentive, friendly service. This sentiment echoes throughout other guest experiences, highlighting a commitment to making each visitor feel welcomed and valued. Michael Burrell’s recollection of celebrating his aunt's 90th birthday at the Lodge underscores its suitability for creating cherished family moments, supported by a team of top-notch employees.
For those looking for a long-standing favorite spot, Helen R.'s testimonial about enjoying Heartlake Lodge’s pizza and wings for over a decade speaks volumes. Whether dining in or opting for takeout, the consistently delicious offerings solidify the Lodge’s reputation as a reliable and beloved culinary destination.
Heartlake Lodge is more than just a place to eat or stay; it's a community hub where good food, great company, and natural beauty converge. It invites guests to slow down, savor local flavors, and make lasting memories by the lake. For anyone seeking a blend of relaxation, social engagement, and authentic regional hospitality, Heartlake Lodge delivers in spades.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Very nice little bar/restaurant just outside of town. I didn't get food, but based on the crowd, and the number of takeouts, (and how good the wings smelled!). I figure it is pretty good. 5 beers on tap, 3 regular domestics and 2 heartier brews. Live music on Friday, I will certainly be back for a dinner.
What a beautiful place, right by the lake, the food was excellent and the service was great, friendly and prompt.
I attended my Aunt's 90th birthday party here . Beautiful place and top notch employees
This has been one of my favorite places to get pizza and wings for the last decade. It's always my go to when I don't know where I want to get food from. Whether you eat in or done out, it's delicious. Sometimes they are quite busy, but it's expected.
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Discover Hockenberry's Juniata Hotel at 42 E Main St, Everett, PA. Enjoy a welcoming, oldtimey saloon vibe, top business amenitie...
1722 Motor Lodge offers clean, quiet, and accessible rooms with free WiFi and parking in Lancaster, PA. Enjoy kitchenequipped ro...
Waterfront Inn PHL Airport offers clean, newly renovated rooms with scenic river views, comfortable beds, and easy access to Phila...
Discover Little Buffalo State Park Recreation Hall, a toprated 4.5star destination in Newport, PA. Ideal for special events and ...
Experience clean, wellequipped rooms with kitchenettes, free WiFi, and breakfast included at The Anuva Hotel in Spring City, PA....
Ridgemont Motel offers a 4.5star experience with spacious, airconditioned rooms featuring private terraces and kitchenettes. Loc...
King's Inn Hotel offers clean, newly renovated rooms and studiostyle extended stays in York, PA. Enjoy free WiFi, free parking, ...
Experience the charm of Laurel Manor Motel, a cozy momandpop lodging with spacious rooms, welcoming staff, and a quiet atmospher...
Discover Stardust Motel, a welcoming 3.8rated lodging in Carlisle, PA. Enjoy wellmaintained rooms, peaceful surroundings, free W...
Discover Westwood Villas on Holly Forest Rd, Lake Harmony, PA. Enjoy spacious, clean accommodations with free WiFi, pool, hot tub...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
